Many of the liberal commentators in the mediasphere are claiming victory. "See?" they say. "All of our efforts are paying off. President Obama is finally listening to us. Our incessant cries and drumbeats that he is a corporatist shill for Big Banks, Big Oil, and Big Business have finally brought him to his senses."
Lost in this conversation is the reality that Barack Obama has stood for "the other 98%" for his entire adult life. Even a cursory review of his biography shows that he has been a champion for the poor, for unions, and for the middle class for as long as he has been in politics. But Barack Obama is also a pragmatist. He learned his community organizing from a group called the Gamaliel Foundation, and was hired by a man named Mike Kruglik. I have attended trainings by Kruglik and wrote a piece called "I Want POWER and I Will Be Ruthless" that describes it. Here's a snippet of that post:
The Gamaliel Ladder is basically composed of Values & Faith as the core ideals from which all of our actions are based. These are the things we're willing to stand up to defend.
In order to achieve our goals, we must grasp the reins of POWER, the second rung of the Gamaliel Ladder. Yes, POWER. Without power, we have nothing because we will be able to accomplish nothing. We are told that "power corrupts" and many of us have been hurt by the wanton use of power. But this is because the power was wielded by people with different core values than us.
We must use power ruthlessly to achieve our goals, to further our own SELF-INTEREST, the third rung on the Gamaliel Ladder. And we must use the self-interests of others to get them to work on our behalf. Note that I use the phrase "self-interest" and not "selfishness". Self-interest is the advancement of oneself IN CONCERT with others. Selfishness is the advancement of oneself at the EXPENSE of others.
The concepts of power, self-interest and ruthlessness have been cast in such a way as to make those who have no power shy away from trying to obtain power. But the time has come for us to shed our ambivalence to obtain power and to change the world in ways the further the Progressive Liberal agenda. We can do this with no reservation and we can do this ruthlessly because our actions are based on values that most of the country agrees with:
Safety and Security for our citizens
Prosperity for everyone
Solidarity with the oppressed
Children and families
Equal Opportunity for all
The Gamaliel process for choosing issues to work on involves two key components:
1. Can we win it?
2. Does it build coalitions and strengthen the organization?
These are the basic building blocks, the very basis from which President Obama approaches every major intitiative he gets involved in. He is a pragmatist. He will not get involved in battles he does not believe he can win and he will approach them in a manner that builds coalitions and strengthens his position in future battles.
The key part of this recipe is coalition-building. In this country, particularly at the level the president operates, nothing can be accomplished by working alone. When you look at every major piece of legislation that was supported by the president and that was eventually passed, it was only by getting people from all sides of the issue to get on board that he was able to achieve victory.
Our country has never been more polarized politically than it is right now. Achieving consensus between disparate groups has never been more difficult, particularly in Congress. When you look at what the Obama administration has achieved legislatively, every one of the achievements involved getting the American public behind it and encouraging them to pressure their representatives in Congress to move in the right direction. Health insurance reform. Wall Street reform. Ending Don't Ask, Don't Tell. In order to accomplish this, the American public must be convinced that it is important enough to pay attention to, to act on, and to FIGHT for.
The "new" populist Obama we are seeing today is not new; it has always been there. The emergence of this "New Obama" is simply a matter of timing. He needed to wait until mainstream America woke up to the realities of what the Republicans and other conservatives in this country are doing and what they represent. It has taken two and half years for most of America to realize the Republicans aren't acting on behalf of average Americans. They (and, frankly, some of their Democratic representatives) are acting on behalf of those with the most money and power in this country. Big Banks, Big Oil, Big Business and Big Wealth. To the extent that these politicians have power, they derive it from the resources, mainly cash, coming from these groups.
So, for the past two and half years, President Obama has, often quietly, fed them lengths of rope. A concession here. A backtrack there. Compromise after compromise with hostage-taking conservatives bent on making sure he doesn't succeed in anything that he does, even if it harms the country. And it does harm the country; we see that in spades today. Nobody who is paying any attention at all can continue to believe that Republicans are acting responsibly. When they defend to their last gasp the massive tax breaks given to wealthy individuals and large corporations or the federal tax monies given as subsidies to the most profitable companies in the history of civilization, their motives become crystal clear.
Now, with the impeccable sense of timing and stategic purpose & action that Barack Obama is known for, he is reeling that rope back in. Only now the Republicans have it so tightly wound around their necks that they are being strangled by it. Americans now see them for the obstructionist, self-serving partisans that they are. Now that the administration is calling on Americans to rise up and demand fairness, it a clarion call backed by months and months of clear evidence that what he is doing is right and proper and decent and fair. It's what Americans want and, with the economy still struggling while the wealthy sit on their money and refuse to invest or hire, people are angry. The president has helped them to finally focus their anger on the right groups.
Liberals have been claiming for a long time now that the Obama administration was taking them for granted; that their support was presumed and, because of this, that they weren't being listened to. Part 1 of that belief is true. Their support IS presumed. An August Gallup poll showed that President Obama enjoys a 72% approval rating among liberals. But, Part 2? Not so much. It's not the liberals that President Obama is or has been pitching to. It's middle America. It's the people who don't always pay attention but can be motivated to go to the polls if they have a reason to. It's all of those people who, in 2008, said, "I've voted Republican my whole life but this year, I'm voting for a Democrat."
In other words, President Obama has been slowly and quietly moving the conversation of America to his framing. He has done all of the things he had to do to get his initiatives passed but he has also given the Republicans a broad stage on which to act out their true intent in full view of the American voters. President Obama didn't move left. He isn't finally doing what progressives have told him to do all along. He is executing perfect timing in a much broader strategy -- a strategy which brings America to his position which is far to the left of today's Republicans, a divide which is only growing deeper and wider with every utterance of Michele Bachmann, Rick Perry, Rick Santorum, John Boehner, Eric Cantor, Mitch McConnell and every other blathering tea partier in our country.
The talking heads on the left can claim all the credit they want. At the end of the day, I don't give a damn how we got here. But their contention that they are responsible for it denies the reality that pragmatic progressives ("pragprogs" as I call them) have know from the start. This president takes a much longer view than they do. He's patient. He's strategic. And he is a true progressive that values PROGRESS over grandstanding.
All photos by Anne C. Savage. Please do not reuse without permission. Seriously. I mean that. Ask first.
Cross-posted from Eclectablog.