So in the "progressive" Firedoglake we can find the horrifying, but expected news.
"Progressive News": "Pelosi Shifts the Goalposts – Now Draws Line on Bush Tax Cuts at $1 Million".
Ooh, a favorite story for the "progressives" and the GOP : Democratic Wimps Cave Again. Proof?
Regressive "News": "House Minority Leader, Nancy Pelosi,[...] fired off a letter to the Speaker asking for immediate consideration of an extension of just the “low end” tax cuts – which include the Bush-era marginal rates for households making up to $1 million. This represents a shift in the dividing line for the Bush tax cuts, which has traditionally been at $250,000.
You see Democrats don't know how to negotiate as well as genius progressive bloggers who know that digging in always works - that's how Custer won at the Little Big Horn, after all.
Reality: [in 2010] "Senate Democrats offered to extend the tax cuts for income up to $1 million, not Mr. Obama’s proposal of $250,000 per couple limit."
So Democrats have always set the line at $250K except when they didn't. And it couldn't be that Pelosi knows Boehner will never bring it up so she's trying to make the contrast of Democratic and GOP positions as stark as possible: she has to be "negotiating with herself".
The regressive analysis: "When the dividing line was $250,000 a year, the revenue was around $800 billion over a ten-year period. I don’t have a strong grasp of what the numbers would be at $1 million, but my guess would be half that, if not more. So from a deficit reduction standpoint, this makes pretty much no sense."
"Guess"? Where oh where could we find an actual analysis of how much is saved?
"let me just say about these high-end tax cuts: 80 percent of the tax cuts go to people making over $1 million a year — people making over $1 million a year." - Nancy Pelosi in 2010.
UPDATE: Poor thin skinned Mr. Dayen responds by calling me a "professional troll" and explaining the the marginal tax rate. The problem is that when you insist that the goalposts have moved and 10 seconds of google work shows that Democrats have proposed both the $250K and $1M figure in the past, you cannot justify your shoddy work by changing the subject (and getting that wrong too).
Progressive "journalism" watch: Goalposts (UPDATED!)
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
TPV Posts
-
▼
2012
(423)
-
▼
May
(47)
- Why is Huffington Post Taking Money from Scott Wal...
- Why they want to buy Mitt
- Logic FAIL: Glenn Greenwald's Big Flip Flop on Jud...
- Barack Obama's betrayal of the progressive program...
- Glenn Greenwald no like us. :-(
- Time for the Left to Give Up Rank Stupidity on Fed...
- C!: Documenting Innocence
- Mark Halperin's Man Crush on Mitt Romney
- President Obam was never the progressive candidate...
- Progressive "journalism" watch: Goalposts (UPDATED...
- The power of example: Americans of color more like...
- The bigger Bain backfire: Priorities USA sees Romn...
- Hitting Romney where it hurts, and why running aro...
- NAACP endorses marriage equality as a civil right
- What GOP strategist's racist attack plan says abou...
- CI: Birthing Behind Bars
- House Democrats fight back against voter suppressi...
- John Boehner is walking into it... again.
- We are all Mayans now
- The Bain of Mitt: How an $83,000 ad buy made Mitt ...
- I have had it with the pious baloney
- CNN's Ashleigh Banfield scrambles to shield Mitt R...
- "That's capitalism"
- The third part of anti-Obama left critiques
- Tax reform, GOP style: You pay more, so the rich c...
- Obama goes after Romney's vampire economics
- TPVideo Cast: Stop using "high school" as an excus...
- Civil rights for all: DOJ files suit against Arpai...
- CI: Faith, Profits & Prisons
- New purist meme: All credit for Obama's marriage e...
- Evolution
- Vindication: History made as Obama backs marriage ...
- The luxurious life of GOP Julia (too bad for the r...
- This is not about a funding dispute
- The GOP is doomed... maybe
- 2012 launch open thread
- TPVideocast: Mitt Romney as stalker in chief, and ...
- Mitt Romney's job creation demand clashes with his...
- What they won't tell you: +827,000 private sector ...
- CI: Tipping Point???
- "A dark day for freedom" turns into a black eye fo...
- Am I supposed to feel sorry for him?
- Elizabeth Warren dismantles Professional Left's "O...
- How dare you attack us?
- Bin Laden is dead and American manufacturing is su...
- Romney can run, but he can't hide his Swiss bank a...
- Her Republican face is showing: Arianna Huffington...
-
▼
May
(47)
Blogroll
-
-
-
"Nothing is more important"1 hour ago
-
Furthermore! – Biceps and Selfishness2 hours ago
-
Federal Funding for Storm Shelters2 hours ago
-
-
Responsible Fiscal Conservatives3 hours ago
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
A GOP Collection of Nursery Rhymes1 day ago
-
-
Forward To The Future?2 weeks ago
-
-
-
-
Sorry Dr. Ride.9 months ago
-
Site Feed
Wednesday, May 23, 2012 |


