So we found out yesterday that Democratic Congressmen John Conyers, Dennis Kucinich and Mike Capuano have joined forces with seven Republicans to sue President Obama for doing something completely legal and in keeping with his basic Constitutional powers: taking action in Libya in support of a unanimous UN Security Council resolution and under NATO command. I have explained previously (once and twice) why the action in Libya is completely legal and expected given the backdrop of our treaty obligations in conjunction with the President's Constitutional authority to conduct foreign policy.
As The Reid Report notes, Conyers refused to hold impeachment hearings against George W. Bush while he was the Chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, but suddenly sees it fit to sue Obama for acting legally.
In terms of policy, this is not complicated. The President has significant powers to conduct foreign policy under the framework of treaties the United States is a signatory to. Both the UN charter and NATO are such treaties, under which the President is acting. The action in Libya was sanctioned by the UN Security Council, and after 10 days or so of lead action, the US handed the lead over to NATO, falling back to a support role for NATO. The United States has obligations under both the UN and the NATO alliance. The President is clearly authorized to act, as both treaties are duly recognized as law in the United States under the Constitution.
Another thing is also clear as a matter of law and policy: Congress has the power to stop even legal use of force by the President through its control of the purse strings. Even when the President is perfectly within the law in using military force, Congress can simply say, "No, we don't like it; we're cutting off the funds." Members of Congress, Conyers included, are free to pursue that option, and the way the news media is drumming out the "bipartisan" nature of this group suing the President, why are Conyers and his friends such chickens? Why try to get the courts to do their dirty work - which, of course, courts will decline to do as they usually do not intervene in internal disputes between the executive and the legislative branches of government.
Come to think of it, the House actually already spoke on this. In May, the House voted 416-5 to bar President Obama from using any funds in the Defense appropriations bill to put ground forces in Libya. Note: they did not vote to cut off funding but rather to restrict the use of ground troops, which President Obama is not doing and has made clear that he has no intention of doing. If Congress wants to interject in this, this is their only way.
So this lawsuit is for one purpose and one purpose alone: pure show. Whoever said politics was show-business for ugly people is turning out to be right, even if the 'ugly' objective generally only applies to the motives, rather than physical appearances, of our politicians. You have Speaker of the House John Boehner expressing all sorts of "concerns" about Libya, an operation in concert with NATO and the international community that saved thousands of Libyan lives and enabled the country's own revel forces to fight back against their oppressive regime.
Frankly, if Congress has something to say about this further than they already have in the defense appropriations process, they have to say it in their power of the purse. Either grow a set and try to block funding for it, or shut up about it and stop making an ass out of yourselves and showing the Libyan people that you care more about your theatrics than their life. Put a damn cork in it.
Oh, They're Suing (Also, Late Night Open Thread)
Labels:
Barack Obama,
Congress,
John Conyers,
libya,
open thread
Like this article? Spread the word by sharing!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
TPV Posts
-
▼
2011
(576)
-
▼
June
(41)
- Framing the Debate: Tax Giveaways vs. Investing in...
- Democrats Need a Marriage Counselor
- Obama Does Not Have To Be Forced To Come Out Of Th...
- Sunday night horrors at Daily Kos
- TPV in Professional Left Crosshairs Again: This Ti...
- Gay Marriage, Wall Street and How the Teabaggers G...
- Time to hold feet to the fire and demand accountab...
- A Great Day For NY LGBTQ Community But Rachel Madd...
- Tax-Cut Religion and Republican Crybabies
- Fairness for Workers: Obama Administration Moves t...
- Don't Know What You Got Till It's gone! VOTE or DI...
- New Cop on Wall Street: Consumer Protection Bureau...
- Health Reform in Action: 5.5 Million on Medicare T...
- Suckerpunched: What to do When Jane Hamsher is Jus...
- Principles for Pouters versus Rules for Radicals
- A Pound of Cure: National Prevention Strategy Targ...
- How Dan Choi Hurts the LGBT Movement
- Salon, Washington Times, DailyKos and other right ...
- Oh, They're Suing (Also, Late Night Open Thread)
- The fake debt crisis and the real investment crisi...
- Drama Queen 101 with Professor Glenn Greenwald
- In The Mean Time, American Exports Shoot Up
- The Other American Dream
- One Month Of Bad Data. Stop the Bull$hi$! We Are N...
- When Redistricting Reform Works
- Certifiable Space Case: The Premature Obituary of ...
- Pivot Pivot Pivot
- Lighting More Sparks: Closing the Skills Mismatch ...
- "The dirty trick that launched Anthony Weiner's ca...
- David Swanson's Insult of Tahrir Square is at Once...
- Head Explosions Time! Health Insurance Premiums De...
- "He's not a values guy?" Weiner Must Apologize To ...
- Yes We Ken: Israelis Stand with Obama as Congress ...
- HHS: Planned Parenthood Defunding by States Illega...
- Deficit Reduction: Why the Right Gets it Wrong and...
- Obama Administration, Wall Street Crackdown, and D...
- Breaking down Krugman's fractions
- Emboldened by Obama Administration, California Ass...
- Jim Inhofes Okie Toxic Tutu
- Debt Figures: How PolitiFact Got it Wrong and Nanc...
- Meet Dana Bash, Andrew Breitbart's New Best Friend...
-
▼
June
(41)
Blogroll
-
-
-
-
Carole King’s got a friend….7 hours ago
-
-
-
-
-
Campus Question – May 22, 201311 hours ago
-
-
-
-
-
-
A GOP Collection of Nursery Rhymes2 days ago
-
Forward To The Future?2 weeks ago
-
-
-
-
Sorry Dr. Ride.9 months ago
-
Site Feed
Thursday, June 16, 2011 |

